“Everything that has a beginning, has an ending. Make your peace with that and all will be well.”

Everything-that-has-a-beginning-has-an-ending.-Make-your-peace-with-that-and-all-will-be-well

Elizabeth Laren wrote to me asking about this Fake Buddha Quote, which she spotted on Facebook, where it had been posted by “Blue Buddha Quote Collective”:

“Everything that has a beginning, has an ending. Make your peace with
that and all will be well.”

~ The Buddha

“‘Make your peace with that and all will be well,’ just doesn’t sound like Buddha. The first part, yes,” she wrote.

Actually, I thought the use of “beginning” and “ending” sounded too contemporary as well, although that could simply be a matter of word choice on the part of the translator. As Bhikkhu Yuttadhammo reminded me, there’s a common expression in the Pali canon:

“yaṃ kiñci samudayadhammaṃ, sabbaṃ taṃ nirodhadhamman”ti.
“Whatever is of the nature to arise, all that is of the nature to cease”

These words are often put into the minds of those who experience insight by the compilers of the canon. For example:

Then to Moggallana the wanderer, as he heard this Dhamma exposition, there arose the dustless, stainless Dhamma eye: Whatever is subject to origination is all subject to cessation.

“Everything that has a beginning, has an ending,” as an expression in English, goes back a long way. A book called Immortality: The Principal Philosophic Arguments for and Against It, published in 1904, contains that exact phrase. “Whatever has a Beginning has an End” goes back at least to 1702, and The Lives of the Ancient Philosophers.

A more archaic, and reversed, version of the quote, “There is nothing strictly immortal, but immortality. Whatever hath no beginning may be confident of no end,” is found in Thomas Browne’s book, “Hydriotaphia, Urn Burial, or, a Discourse of the Sepulchral Urns lately found in Norfolk.” Thanks to Eric Kaplan for this information, which led me to look search for further examples of that archaic grammar, and led me to a 1665 book, “Another Collection of Philosophical Conferences of the French Virtuosi,” in which we read:

But amongst the French, I account none more ingenious than the Lawyers, who confute the Philosophical Maxim, which saith, That whatever hath a beginning hath also an end, since they render Suits immortal.

This suggests that we’re dealing with a rather ancient philosophical saying that can’t be attributed to any particular author.

Sometimes a translation or paraphrase from the Pali canon with converge toward a more contemporary saying, presumably because of a kind of memetic resonance in the mind of the author. I suspect that that has happened in this case.

I agreed with Elizabeth that “Make your peace with that and all will be well” sounded off. Very much off; more so than the first part.

I found this quote in a 1995 book by Elizabeth Oates Schuster, Awakenings: The Transformative Function of Writing in a Nursing Home. She gives her source for the quote as being “The Sun” — the magazine, not the UK tabloid — in 1995, although she doesn’t say which month. But there is no further detail.

A little more digging around revealed that this is another of Jack Kornfield’s coinages, from his book, Buddha’s Little Instruction Book, published in 1994, just a year before the Sun picked up the quote and changed the attribution from Kornfield to “Buddha.” It’s an understandable error, since it would be easy to assume that a book with such a title would contain the Buddha’s actual words. But in fact Buddha’s Little Instruction book is Jack Kornfield’s adaptation and understanding of Buddhist teachings — not direct quotations from the scriptures.

If you like it, share it!
Share on TumblrShare on LinkedInShare on Google+Share on FacebookEmail this to someonePin on PinterestShare on StumbleUponTweet about this on Twitter

8 thoughts on ““Everything that has a beginning, has an ending. Make your peace with that and all will be well.””

  1. Of the Comment:
    “Everything with a Beginning,
    has an Ending.”

    I have NOT heard the remainder quoted here.

    AS for the Above Part, THERE ARE PROBLEMS !!
    First, IS in Mathematics !!
    i.e. 22/7; PI; Square Root of 7; Logarithms; Trigonometry; & …
    (NOTE: This LIST HAS NO ENDING !!)

    1. Hi, Dirk.

      I think you’re misapplying the principle here. What the saying means is that anything that comes into being will cease to be. Pi etc are not “things” that have a real existence. They’re abstractions. Any thought you have about pi will come into being and cease to be. Any computer you create to calculate pi will likewise come into being and cease to be.

      1. Dirk Here

        “Cease to be” !!??!!
        ONLY When the Universe Ends ??!!??

        ** “Mathematics”, is an example of Idea Processes !!**
        These “Ideas”, Once Started (Begin)
        HAVE NO ENDING !!

        ** OTHER Ideas **
        There are MANY OTHER Ideas; That HAVE NO END !!
        –MANY ARGUMENTS can be Compared to Ideas,
        BUT HAVE NO CONCLUSION (End !!)
        –The Statement from a Person: “I am Lying.” !!
        This “Statement” HAS NO ENDING to
        it’s “Complexity”/”Logic”/Reasoning !!
        –Reasoning AGAINST this Statement !!

        **The Universe, is also an example !!**
        According to “Current” Science:
        -Our Universe was CREATED (Began)
        INSIDE ANOTHER Universe.
        -WHEN our Universe Collapses,
        it WILL then START EXPANDING AGAIN.
        -As there IS NO LOSS of Energy,
        this Cycle WILL CONTINUE FOREVER !!

        “REFLECTIONS in a Mirror !!**
        (Once Created and Placed)
        IF TWO Reflection “Surfaces” are created,
        and they show the Reflection of the Other Surface
        –Two “Flat Surfaces”, will have EVER SHRINKING
        Images of the Reflection !!
        –IF ONE Surfaces, is SHAPED to
        ENLARGE compared to the distance
        from that Surface and Back Again,
        The REFLECTIONS, WILL CONTINUE
        ON FOR EVER !!

        **A Machine that REPAIRS Itself**
        Once Given (Began) a SPECIFIC “Form”,
        it WILL REPAIR itself FOREVER !!
        (So Long as the SPECIFIC “Form” Exists,
        and the Materials are Available !!)

        1. There are many things I could point out about your examples, but the key thing is this: you need to know what it is that the Buddha was talking about in saying “Whatever is of the nature to arise, all that is of the nature to cease.” What he’s discussing is not the external world per se, but our experience. The Buddha was not attempting to do physics or metaphysics, but to get us to look at the nature of our own consciousness.

          As Bhikkhu Bodhi said, “The world with which the Buddha’s teach-ing is principally concerned is “the world of experience,” and even the objective world is of interest only to the extent that it serves as the necessary external condition for experience. The world is identified with the six sense bases because the latter are the necessary internal condition for experience and thus for the presence of a world. As long as the six sense bases persist, a world will always be spread out before us as the objective range of perception and cognition.”

          It’s the world of experience (the meeting of the inner and outer) that the Buddha is concerned with, because unless we understand the nature of that meeting, we’ll continue to suffer.

          So to apply “Whatever is of the nature to arise, all that is of the nature to cease” to abstract concepts like “pi” or to science-fiction versions of the perpetual motion machine (your self-repairing machine) is to take the quote out of context.

          Similarly, when the Buddha talks about everything being subject to change, that applies to experience, and wouldn’t be invalidated by the discovery of something in the physical world that doesn’t change — because your mind is changing all the time and so your experience of this hypothetical unchanging thing would constantly change!

          But just to take a couple of your examples, even though they’re completely irrelevant to the Buddha’s teaching, two mirrors face to face will only theoretically lead to an infinite regression. Given that mirrors are imperfect reflectors, absorbing some photons and scattering others, there is a limit to the number of iterations. And switch off the lights and you’ll have no reflection at all. The lights are going to go out at some point 🙂

          And your self-repairing machine will need a power source. If that’s in the range of a solar system, then eventually the star will die (possibly consuming the machine, or leaving it powerless). But taking the Buddha’s teaching on impermanence into account, the machine you’re hypothesizing is not a “thing” but a process. In every moment, as it repairs itself, it becomes something new. What it was has ceased to be, and there’s something new come into existence. Actually, looking deeper, there is no existence, but only becoming, or existence is becoming.

          This is what the Buddha meant when he said things like this: “As to that end of the world, friend, where one is not born, does not age, does not die, does not pass away, and is not reborn—I say that it cannot be known, seen, or reached by travelling … However, friend, I say that without having reached the end of the world there is no making an end to suffering. It is, friend, in just this fathom-high carcass endowed with perception and mind that I make known the world, the origin of the world, the cessation of the world, and the way leading to the cessation of the world.”

          “The world” (i.e. our experience of the world) ceases to be a “thing” (something we cling to and take as having a real, permanent, separate existence) when we fully recognize the moment-by-moment change in our experience, which makes “being” impossible.

  2. The Buddha realized that nothing in this world stays the same; everything is in a constant state of change. Pleasurable conditions, favorable circumstances, our relationships with those we hold dear, our health and well-being–any sense of comfort and security we derive from these things is continually threatened by life’s flux and uncertainty, and ultimately by death, the most profound change of all. in order to inevitable sufferings of life aimed at freeing people, you must live without any attachment, make peace with it means you need to understand the fact everything which has a beginning has an ending , even things, nothing stays the same, This expanded sense of self is based on a clear awareness of the interconnected fabric of life which we are part of and which sustains us. When awakened to the reality of our relatedness to all life, we can overcome the fear of change and experience the deeper continuities beyond and beneath the ceaseless flow of change… so conclusion , its the same meaning yet people has change few things to make it more simple for the Quote ,

    1. “Same Meaning” ??!!??
      CLOSE, NOT QUITE !!!!

      “Close” (by Definition)
      MEANS NOT FULLY ACCURATE !!
      There ARE MISTAKES !!
      ( Ideas vs Things vs Processes vs Action vs …)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *